The suggestion to deploy accountants as a tool against human trafficking sounds noble, but is practically unfeasible. Crime cannot be fought with extra checkmarks in files, but with effective enforcement, a higher chance of being caught, and targeted collaboration between regulators and law enforcement agencies.
The European AML legislation is intended to combat money laundering, but expectations have now extended further. Accountants are now also seen as gatekeepers in the fight against human trafficking; a societal task for which they are simply not equipped. As if you can deduce from the annual accounts whether someone is exploiting people. Let's be honest: an accountant prepares, files reports, and sometimes audits an annual account. But no standard audit provides insight into what is happening in the trailer of a truck or at a construction site with a subcontractor.
Also read: Don't be a micromanager
The legislation, including the associated case studies, is substantively interesting, but primarily exposes where things go wrong with a small group of fraudulent accountants and accounting firms. No European regulation can address that. In such cases, regular criminal law is the only correct route. New rules for the entire profession do not solve that problem, but mainly increase the pressure on honest professionals.
This 'mission creep' does not strengthen the profession, but makes it more vulnerable. The rules of the game are practically determined by criminals, who calculate risks as long as their profit model remains lucrative. The costs of additional obligations for accountants are effortlessly factored in. This does not provide protection, but a false sense of security.
Also read: Applying in the AI era
Those who truly want to make an impact must focus on collaboration and information sharing between financial institutions, regulators, and the judiciary. The role of the accountant is to signal and support, but should not be confused with a responsibility for structural misconduct outside their own domain.
As long as that distinction is not sharply monitored, the profession risks collapsing under expectations it has never raised. The societal role of the accountant is significant, but not limitless.
Also read: CEO of Heineken steps down 
